5
Jun

I sometimes wonder, where is the line between non-discretionary and discretionary expenses these days? Slowly, but surely, more items are crossing the line to the non-discretionary side. No wonder it gets harder to find expenses that could be done away with during a recession.

Food, telephone, electricity have been necessary items from long.

People get bored eating the same food – so, a visit to the restaurant once in a while cannot be done away with. And how can I resist the idea of a visit to a mall / shopping complex before the dinner in the restaurant? Oh! I almost forgot the movie before or after the dinner. This is the minimum one has to do to get replenished after a long hard working week. Also, no one can blame me for not spending time with family.

And just landline telephone is too old fashioned these days. Imagine what would happen if someone asks me my number, and I have no cell number to share. How can one live with that trauma for the rest of one’s life? Value added services are the soul of any mobile service. Do you think that I have bought this phone only for sending and receiving calls? Are you out of your mind? And now that I have a cell phone, whenever I have to pass some time, all my contact list is at my fingertips. No longer do I have to sit in a public transport vehicle just looking outside the window and waiting for my stop to come. There is so less time to catch up with all the friends, family – forget the recharge that I have to do every 10 days or so – it is worth it. Moreover, it does not look good if one does not wish others on their birthdays, anniversaries etc.

Electricity has been a boon to mankind. Now, I have a whole range of ‘essential’ electronic items that I can buy. Television has become a part of everyday life. And is it possible to live without air conditioners and heaters given the climate change? I refuse to argue on the essentials such as refrigerator, toasters, juicers, iron, washing machine, audio player etc. Add to these things like DVD player, exercise machine and so on, and you get things without which a home cannot be complete.

I have not even mentioned two modern day essentials – personal vehicles and a laptop – and the set of accessories which are (you got it right) ‘essential’ to the core.

Walking is so passé that unless my doctor / physical trainer tells me to do so, my first step outside my home would be in my car. And not any car – one which is the highest model available within that particular species. Even if it is not the most fuel efficient and our home could have done with a cheaper car, this is a matter of status and that has to be carefully built. Don’t you know how difficult it is to travel by public transport these days? I know that thousands travel that way, but also thousands travel by cars. Are the car owners mad to buy these vehicles? When they can, why can’e we?

Laptop with the best configuration, graphics card, speakers etc. is something important for the kids these days. They need to start getting exposure to such modern technology from the time they are a foetus. Have you heard of the 16Mbps connection that is available in the market? So, what if the only work I do on the internet is checking my mails (and most of it is spam) – anything below 16Mbps is just too slow. I don’t like to be restricted when it comes to the amount of downloads I can do in a month. So, the unlimited plan looks the ideal for me.

Given all this, it is but natural that recession hits poor souls like me, the most. As you can understand from above, I am just living hand to mouth and there is practically no scope for cutbacks. I am so careful about my expenses, that there is hardly any discretionary expense that I can enjoy or have some savings for the future.

(Ashutosh is a recent graduate from IIM Ahemdabad. Before that he worked at Lehman Brothers and has done his undergrad at IIT Delhi in Computer Science Engineering.)

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

Related posts:

  1. The ABCD of Tata Croma’s newly-wed offer
  2. I want to pay tax like a company!
  3. Of Hybrids and EVs
  4. Official Leaves: Time to revamp them?
  5. Distribution – Redefined – Part 1

Category : Planning / Public Issues

5 Responses to “There is no room for cutbacks!”


Abhijit June 5, 2009

Very well written post! Do not know bout others but at least I saw a reflection of myself (albeit in some parts) in the post.
Although my view-point on the necessity of cut-backs is not from the recessionary viewpoint only but also from the over-consumption that this earth suffers from. It is good for the individual but not in the best interests of the larger population.

The best part of the post for me was the common psyche these days
“I am just living hand to mouth and there is practically no scope for cutbacks. I am so careful about my expenses, that there is hardly any discretionary expense that I can enjoy or have some savings for the future.”

Gaurav Parashar June 5, 2009

Well presented! It reminds me of “Rich Dad Poor Dad”, dont invest your money into assets with no returns. Invest in assets which produce perinneal cash flows. Apt for atleast the early years of life!

shubham June 5, 2009

I guess that is what they mean by rise in the standard of living :P …. India is also becoming a consumerist society and I feel the trend is only going to grow with more items to fall into the non-discretionary list.

Nitin Parmar June 7, 2009

This was precisely the thinking of lot of americans before Sept 2007. They were not in a position to differentiate between needs & wants, requirements & luxury. Wants and Luxury are backed by capability to pay. One should never forget about economics of his own.

Anyways, Good representation of ideas!